So far in my relatively brief life, I have owned zero televisions. As I was thinking about that some time ago, I realized it might be a good idea to keep it that way. What? No Television? (8:15) Don’t worry, I’m not saying that tv does nothing but rot your brain…I’m just saying that it does little else. While it’s true that there is some quality television, even this minority suffers from some basic flaws:
It is sedentary - As you all know, Americans are obese, and television helps keep us that way. Is there anything else I need to say about this?
It is non-interactive - Television, with little exception, does not require or allow any audience participation. We just sit and let our minds be filled with….whatever we’re watching. This is a category where video games do a little better, at least requiring some modicum of thought and activity.
It takes a lot of time - Watching one tv show is a fairly reasonable 30min-1hr. Bump that up to two or three and you might be spending a whole third of your conscious day on tv. Watch a movie, there’s 2-3 hours, or a football game, there goes 4. Also, at least in my experience, tv is very addictive. Once I’ve settled in with hulu, it takes some determination to get back up again.
It does not encourage social interaction - Depending on genre (this doesn’t apply to sports so much as movie theaters for instance), television can seriously discourage people from talking to eachother. How sad to be sitting in the same room and not conversing for the sake of mindless entertainment.
It does not encourage brain activity - I am of course aware that most of the above categories apply to activities I would generally call praiseworthy, such as reading books or listening to music. However, this is where tv really shines. The black box requires nothing of you…just that you sit and absorb its content. A book at least forces you to translate print into ideas. Even the poorest fiction requires your brain to work to imagine its events.
Thought experiment - what if each of us exchanged all the time we spend on tv for one other activity? Would we be better people if we traded it for:
Reading a book - the Bible, for instance?
Writing a book?
Practicing an art…an instrument, drawing, photography, composition?
Learning something new?
A project…programming, home improvement, organization?
PT?
Conversation with family and friends?
Napping?
Anyway, this is not a fully-developed idea, just some thoughts that I’ve been bouncing around. Personally, I haven’t cut out all tv; right now my pattern is to watch a single show on hulu over dinner. I certainly welcome any comments on stuff I overlooked.
UPDATE - Not too long after I wrote this post, I discovered John Piper’s blog and his post, Why I Don’t Have a Television and Rarely Go to Movies.